If you need a new roof or a repair in Elkhart, you’re going to compare a few contractors before you decide. You should. We’re Better Way Roofing, and honestly, we’d rather you put our quote next to one or two others than just take our word for it. So we’ve reviewed six roofing companies serving the Elkhart area the same way we’d want to be reviewed: fairly, and with the details that actually matter.
A&M Home Services
Key Service: Full-spectrum exterior remodeling with a flagship focus on GAF-certified residential roof replacement
What Stands Out:
A&M is one of the largest roofing contractors in Northern Indiana, with six office locations across the region (the nearest to Elkhart being Plymouth and South Bend). They hold GAF Master-Elite status, a credential awarded to fewer than 2% of roofing contractors nationwide, and have earned the GAF Triple Excellence Award. Beyond roofing, they offer gutters, siding, windows, and waterproofing, making them a one-stop option for larger exterior projects. With over 1,150 Google reviews at 4.9 stars and an A+ BBB rating (accredited since 2014), their track record is well documented.
"He gave me a very thorough estimate with no hidden costs. I knew exactly what I was getting and how much I would pay." — Virginia C., Elkhart
"Crew showed up on promised day, worked quickly and efficiently, finishing before schedule. Cleanup was exceptional." — Sandra N., Granger
Fit For:
- Homeowners planning multiple exterior projects at once (roof, siding, gutters, windows)
- Buyers who prioritize manufacturer credentials and want access to GAF's strongest warranties
- Customers who value a large, established company with a deep operational footprint
Not Ideal For:
- Homeowners on a tight budget looking for the lowest bid. A&M's pricing reflects their certifications and overhead across six locations.
- Customers who prefer a smaller, owner-on-site operation. A&M is a mid-size company with a more corporate structure.
Equity Roofing
Key Service: Owens Corning Platinum Preferred roof replacement with a 25-year workmanship warranty
What Stands Out:
Equity Roofing holds Owens Corning Platinum Preferred status, the highest tier in the Owens Corning contractor program. Fewer than 1% of roofing contractors nationally earn this designation. Their Goshen-based Indiana team, managed by Matthew Schlabach, serves the wider Elkhart County area. They also won Owens Corning's Service and Product Excellence Awards in both 2025 and 2026. Their inspection process is repeatedly praised in reviews as more thorough than competitors, and they offer roof rejuvenation (an oil-based treatment to extend roof life) as an alternative to full replacement.
"The initial inspection was thorough, much more extensive than either of the other two companies." — Ben O., Elkhart
"My roof was replaced in only one day and the crew was diligent about cleaning up after themselves." — Nikki S., Goshen
Fit For:
- Homeowners who want the strongest Owens Corning warranty available (25-year workmanship, 50-year transferable system warranty)
- Buyers who value a detailed inspection process and want an honest assessment before committing to a full replacement
- Customers interested in roof rejuvenation as a lower-cost alternative to replacement
Not Ideal For:
- Commercial or flat-roof projects. Equity is residential only with no TPO, PVC, or low-slope capability.
- Customers who specifically check BBB by state. The Indiana division does not have its own BBB profile (the Pennsylvania headquarters holds A+ accreditation).
- Homeowners looking for a company with deep, long-term roots in Indiana, or who value dealing directly with the owner. Equity's Indiana branch only opened in 2023, and the company's ownership, history, and largest team are in Central Pennsylvania.
Relentless Roofing Co.
Key Service: Insurance claim-focused roof replacement with a lifetime workmanship warranty, based directly in Elkhart
What Stands Out:
Relentless Roofing is headquartered on US-33 in Elkhart, making them one of the few reviewed companies physically based in the city itself. They have built a strong reputation around insurance claim support, reporting that they have recovered nearly $2 million for homeowners and overturned more than 500 denied claims. With 309 Google reviews at a perfect 5.0 stars, their customer satisfaction numbers are hard to argue with. They complete 90% of jobs in a single day.
"They were comfortably 25% less expensive than the competition for similar products. A crew of 5 stripped my old roof and replaced the whole thing in one and a half days." — Matt B.
"They kept me informed through the whole process. Came the day of, cleaned up everything, and workers were very polite!" — Tina C.
Fit For:
- Homeowners dealing with storm or hail damage who need help navigating the insurance claim process
- Buyers who want the convenience of a contractor based directly in Elkhart
- Price-conscious customers. Multiple reviewers report competitive pricing compared to other local contractors.
Not Ideal For:
- Homeowners who want a single in-house crew. Relentless subcontracts its installation work, so if you value the kind of roofing where one company's own team does the job and the owner knows every crew member by name, it is worth knowing that is not how they operate.
- Homeowners who prioritize company longevity. Relentless was incorporated in 2018 and is roughly seven to eight years old. Their marketing references "20+ years of experience," which refers to founder TJ Meehan's personal career, not the company's age.
- Customers who rely on BBB accreditation as a trust signal. Relentless is not accredited by the BBB.
- Large-scale commercial projects. Their focus is residential and light commercial.
Sherriff Goslin Roofing
Key Service: Proprietary Art-Loc interlocking shingles with a 10-year free service guarantee, backed by 120 years of Midwest roofing experience
What Stands Out:
Sherriff Goslin is the oldest roofing company in this review by a wide margin. Founded in 1906 in Battle Creek, Michigan, they opened their South Bend branch in 1920 and now operate 17 locations across Michigan, Indiana, and Ohio. Their most distinctive offering is the Art-Loc shingle, a patented interlocking diamond-pattern product manufactured exclusively for Sherriff Goslin. No other contractor can install it. They hold Atlas Platinum-Level certification (Atlas Roofing's highest tier) and employ full-time safety monitors on their crews.
"I called on Sunday evening and they were finished with the repair before noon on Wednesday. I highly recommend Bobby and his team." — Aaron C.
"The entire process was stress free and everything they promised was executed beyond our imagination." — Stephanie I.
Fit For:
- Homeowners interested in a proprietary shingle product that no other contractor offers
- Buyers who value a long-established company with generational experience and a dedicated project manager on every job
- Customers who need both residential and commercial roofing from the same contractor
Not Ideal For:
- Homeowners who prioritize post-installation responsiveness. A recurring pattern across complaint platforms is difficulty reaching the company for warranty claims and follow-up service after the initial job is complete.
- Customers who prefer a locally owned, owner-on-site contractor. Sherriff Goslin is a regional chain. The nearest branch is in Mishawaka, not Elkhart.
- Budget-focused buyers. Their proprietary products and structured project management process typically carry a higher price point.
Shield Exteriors
Key Service: Residential metal roofing specialist with a transferable lifetime accident-free warranty
What Stands Out:
Shield Exteriors is one of the few contractors in the region that leads with metal roofing rather than offering it as an afterthought. Based in Garrett, Indiana, they serve over 45 counties across Northeast Indiana, Northwest Ohio, and Southern Michigan. They won the 2022 BBB Torch Award for Business Integrity and hold an A+ BBB rating with zero complaints since accreditation in 2017. Their signature offering is a "True Double Lifetime Accident-Free Warranty" on all metal roof installations, covering storms, accidents, and acts of nature, and fully transferable to a new homeowner.
"These guys were super nice, knowledgeable, and didn't push. The warranty is unbelievable and the work was completed in 2 days." — Lisa S.
"The crew arrived at the time I was told; they were courteous and kept me informed of their progress throughout the day." — Tracy B.
Fit For:
- Homeowners who have decided on metal roofing and want a contractor that specializes in it rather than treating it as a sideline
- Buyers who value a transferable warranty that covers accidental damage, not just defects
- Customers looking for a company with a spotless BBB record and an independent integrity award
Not Ideal For:
- Commercial or flat-roof projects. Shield is residential only.
- Homeowners who just want a straightforward asphalt shingle replacement. Shield offers asphalt, but their identity, expertise, and pricing are built around metal.
- Customers who want a named manufacturer certification (Owens Corning, GAF, CertainTeed). Shield does not publicly display any manufacturer-level credential.
Moreno's Roofing LLC
Key Service: Residential roofing and storm damage restoration with bilingual (English/Spanish) service
What Stands Out:
Moreno's is a family-owned operation based directly in Elkhart at 30877 Old US 20. Founded in 2015 by Juan Moreno, who has been in the roofing industry since 2010, the company focuses on residential shingle and metal roofing with a strong emphasis on insurance claim assistance. They hold an A+ BBB rating (accredited since 2020), are listed as an Owens Corning contractor, and work with CertainTeed shingles and Central States Manufacturing metal systems. With 102 Google reviews at 4.7 stars, they are a smaller operation than some others on this list, but their bilingual service fills a real gap in the Elkhart market.
"Juan and his crew did an excellent job on our new roof. $1,600 lower than another bid with the same materials. These hard workers finished the job in two long days." — Tim S.
"Once the crew started working on the roof they barely took breaks, only for lunch. These people work hard and quickly." — Noe S., South Bend
Fit For:
- Spanish-speaking homeowners who want to communicate directly with their contractor in their first language
- Budget-conscious buyers. Multiple reviews highlight competitive pricing compared to larger contractors.
- Customers who prefer a small, owner-operated company where Juan is personally involved in the work
Not Ideal For:
- Large commercial projects. Moreno's focus is residential.
- Buyers looking for a company that specializes in metal roofing.
- Buyers who rely heavily on review volume as a trust signal. At 102 Google reviews, their track record is solid but thinner than larger competitors.
How These Companies Compare
For full transparency, we have added Better Way Roofing to the bottom of the table and marked it clearly as the publisher of this article. We are not part of the ranked review above. This simply lets you compare us on the same measures.
| Company | Years | Credential | Warranty | BBB | Reviews | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A&M Home Services | 15 | GAF Master-Elite | Lifetime (GAF) | A+ accredited | 1,157 / 4.9★ | Whole-house exterior projects |
| Equity Roofing | 3 (IN, since 2023) | OC Platinum Preferred | 25-year | A+ (PA entity) | ~170 / 5.0★ | Strongest OC warranty |
| Relentless Roofing | 8 | OC certified | Lifetime | Not accredited | 309 / 5.0★ | Insurance claim navigation |
| Sherriff Goslin | 120 | Atlas Platinum / Art-Loc | 10-year service | A+ accredited | ~90 / 4.6★ | Proprietary shingles |
| Shield Exteriors | 10 | BBB Torch Award | Lifetime (transferable) | A+ accredited | ~809 / 4.8★ | Metal roofing specialists |
| Moreno's Roofing | 11 | CertainTeed Contractor | Not published | A+ accredited | 102 / 4.7★ | Bilingual, competitive pricing |
| Better Way Roofing Publisher of this review |
10+ | Owens Corning Preferred | Lifetime | A+ | 302 / 5.0★ | Local, no-pressure team |
Choosing the Right Roofer for Your Elkhart Home
A&M Home Services is the right call if you are planning a larger exterior renovation and want one contractor to handle roofing, siding, gutters, and windows under a single project. Their GAF Master-Elite status unlocks the strongest manufacturer warranties in the GAF program.
Equity Roofing stands out for homeowners who want the highest-tier Owens Corning warranty available. Their Platinum Preferred status (top 1% nationally) and thorough inspection process make them a strong choice for anyone comparing shingle options carefully.
Relentless Roofing Co. is one of the few companies on this list based in Elkhart itself, and their insurance claim expertise is a genuine specialty. If you are dealing with storm damage and need someone who knows how to work with adjusters, they have the track record.
Sherriff Goslin brings something no one else can: 120 years of continuous operation and a proprietary shingle that no other contractor installs. If longevity and a unique product matter to you, they deserve a conversation. Just be aware that their post-installation service has drawn some criticism.
Shield Exteriors is the clear pick if you have already decided on a metal roof. They are one of the few contractors in the region whose entire business is built around metal roofing, and their transferable lifetime accident-free warranty is the strongest metal warranty in this review.
Moreno's Roofing fills an important gap as a bilingual, family-owned contractor based in Elkhart. Their pricing is consistently competitive, and they bring a hands-on, owner-involved approach that larger companies cannot match.
FAQ
How do I verify a roofing contractor's credentials in Indiana?
Indiana does not require a statewide roofing license, but requirements vary by city and municipality: some require a contractor license, others only ask you to register your business, and the work itself usually needs permits. Beyond local rules, credentials come from manufacturer certifications (like GAF Master-Elite or Owens Corning Platinum Preferred) and third-party ratings (BBB, Google reviews). Always ask any contractor for proof of liability insurance and workers' compensation coverage before signing a contract.
What is the difference between a BBB rating and BBB accreditation?
A BBB rating (A+ through F) is assigned by the Better Business Bureau based on complaint history and business practices. BBB accreditation is a separate, paid status that requires the business to meet additional standards and agree to BBB's dispute resolution process. A company can hold an A+ rating without being accredited.
Should I choose a local Elkhart roofer or a regional company?
Both have advantages. A local contractor like Relentless Roofing or Moreno's Roofing is physically based in Elkhart and may offer more accessible communication and faster response times. Regional companies like A&M Home Services or Sherriff Goslin bring broader resources, multiple office locations, and often stronger manufacturer certifications. The right choice depends on the size of your project and what matters most to you.
What does Owens Corning Platinum Preferred mean compared to regular Owens Corning certification?
Owens Corning has several tiers. A basic "Owens Corning contractor" is listed in their directory. "Preferred" contractors meet higher standards for volume and customer satisfaction. "Platinum Preferred" is the top tier, held by fewer than 1% of contractors nationally. The main practical difference for homeowners is warranty length: Platinum Preferred contractors can offer a 25-year workmanship warranty backed by Owens Corning itself, while lower tiers typically offer 10 years or less.